Wooriyeojido한국어 · English · 日本語Get the app

Where Did Columbus First Land in 1492? The White Cross at Long Bay, San Salvador, Bahamas

Which island did Christopher Columbus reach on 12 October 1492? A look at the cross on Long Bay in the Bahamas, a scholarly debate that has never been settled, and the Lucayan people who lived on the island first.

Written and compiled by the Wooriyeojido team · · About the operator

On 12 October 1492, Christopher Columbus's ships reached an island in the Caribbean. More than five centuries later, nobody can say for certain which island it was. Our story starts at a slender white cross on a beach in the Bahamas and goes back further still, to the Lucayan people who called the island home before any European arrived. Watch the short video first.

Black-and-white photograph of the white memorial cross at Long Bay, San Salvador Island, Bahamas
Photo: Unknown author (U.S. Air Force photograph, NARA) · Public domain · Source
Where Did Columbus First Land in 1492? The White Cross at Long Bay, San Salvador, BahamasWatch the one-minute video on YouTube

A small island on the edge of the Atlantic

San Salvador is a small island on the eastern, Atlantic side of the Bahamas. At Long Bay, on its west coast, a tall white cross marks the spot where Columbus is believed to have come ashore. According to the Bahamas tourism ministry, the monument was put up in 1956, and a black-and-white photograph from 1958 already shows it standing on the beach.

White coral sand and clear turquoise water along a beach in the Bahamas
Photo: Jack Kennard · CC BY 2.0 · Source

Two months at sea

Sailing for the Spanish crown, Columbus left the port of Palos in southern Spain on 3 August 1492 with three ships. According to the Florida Museum of Natural History, after a September stop at La Gomera in the Canary Islands the fleet made no further landfall. Then, at about two in the morning on 12 October, land finally appeared.

The people living there, the Lucayans, called their island Guanahani. Columbus gave it a new name, San Salvador, "Holy Saviour." In the words of the Bahamian prime minister, he "drove a sword into the earth" and declared the land the property of the Spanish crown.

Waves washing over the white sand at Fernandez Bay on the west coast of San Salvador
Photo: James St. John · CC BY 2.0 · Source

An island that was already home

The island was anything but empty. The Lucayans were the original inhabitants of the Bahamas, part of the broader Taíno culture of the Caribbean. The prime minister has described them as skilled fishermen, hunters and farmers who made remarkable work in clay, stone and wood. Island names such as Inagua, Mayaguana and Exuma come from the Lucayans. The British Museum holds a Taíno ceremonial seat, called a duho, that was found on the Bahamian island of Eleuthera.

A carved wooden duho, a Taíno ceremonial seat
Photo: Jononmac46 · CC0 · Source

What came next was devastating. National Geographic's education materials note that Columbus took several Lucayans as slaves and that the colonizers who followed did the same. Through enslavement, killing and diseases such as smallpox, the Lucayan people were all but wiped out in less than 30 years.

So which island was it?

The true identity of Guanahani is still argued over. As the Florida Museum puts it, scholars agree that it lies somewhere in the Bahamas, "but that is where agreement ends." Ten different islands have been put forward as the first landfall, and in 1986 National Geographic magazine told its 40 million readers that the answer was Samana Cay.

Even so, the most widely accepted candidate is the island now called San Salvador. It was once known as Watling Island, and its official name was changed to San Salvador in the 1920s.

Portrait of a man said to be Christopher Columbus
Photo: Sebastiano del Piombo · Public domain · Source

The short answer, then: most scholars believe today's San Salvador is where Columbus first set foot, but rival theories pointing to other islands have never gone away.

Remembering the first inhabitants

On 12 October 2022, exactly 530 years after Columbus arrived, the prime minister of the Bahamas opened an exhibition called "Lucayans: The Valor of the Vanquished." In his speech, he said the nation has a duty to honour and remember the islands' original inhabitants.

Close-up of the white sand on the beach by the Columbus Monument
Photo: James St. John · CC BY 2.0 · Source

Find Long Bay, San Salvador on Wooriyeojido

It is the island most often named as Columbus's first landfall, and the island the Lucayans lived on long before that. The white cross at Long Bay is pinned on the Wooriyeojido map. Look it up in the app, and when you visit, add your own photos and stories right beside it.

View this place in the Wooriyeojido app
View the full playlist

Sources